Chapter 8: THE MAN WHO BELIEVED EVERYTHING HAD A PRICE
Harlan Voss rode toward the ranch with fourteen armed men and one territorial deputy marshal.
The badge caught Eli’s eye first.
Then Voss.
He did not resemble the villain Eli had imagined.
He was neither huge nor scarred.
He did not dress like a gunfighter.
Harlan Voss appeared to be somewhere around forty-five, clean-shaven and carefully dressed in a pale shirt beneath a dark coat despite the heat.
He looked like a banker.
The kind of man who understood that paperwork could accomplish things bullets made unnecessarily messy.
Deputy Marshal Franklin Kerr rode beside him.
Eli knew Kerr.
The man passed through the district a couple of times each year, delivered official notices, accepted too much whiskey, and generally tried not to become involved in local disputes.
Today he looked deeply uncomfortable.
Voss looked entirely at ease.
They stopped at the gate.
Eli stepped onto the porch by himself.
Chaska had wanted to stand with him.
Eli had refused.
“Why?” she asked.
“He expects this confrontation to be about me.”
“It is not.”
“I know.”
Eli met her eyes.
“That is why.”
Now he faced Voss alone.
Voss smiled.
“Mr. Mercer.”
“Harlan Voss.”
“I believe there has been some misunderstanding.”
“No misunderstanding.”
“You received my offer.”
“Burned it.”
Voss’s smile narrowed.
“Yes. Geller’s horse returned without Geller. I assumed the discussion had become more difficult.”
“Geller is alive.”
“How charitable.”
Voss glanced toward the barn.
Then toward the house windows.
“I understand you have visitors.”
“Not enough coffee for all of you.”
“That will not be necessary.”
Voss removed a document from his coat.
The deputy marshal shifted in his saddle.
Voss continued.
“I am here to assume possession under an emergency lien.”
Eli laughed.
“A what?”
“Your property carries outstanding obligations relating to boundaries and water infrastructure.”
“I owe nobody anything.”
“That is disputed.”
“By whom?”
Voss lifted the paper.
“A court.”
Kerr spoke uneasily.
“Mercer, there is an order.”
Eli looked at him.
“You read the whole thing?”
Kerr’s eyes moved away.
That was answer enough.
Voss spoke pleasantly.
“You can leave this evening with your horses and your personal belongings. I have no interest in being unreasonable.”
Eli walked down from the porch.
Voss watched him.
“Answer something for me.”
“Certainly.”
“Why put this much effort into one little ranch?”
Voss raised an eyebrow.
“For this property?”
“Yes.”
For the first time, Voss seemed almost pleased.
“At last.”
He dismounted.
His men remained alert.
“The territory is changing, Mercer. Railroads are expanding. Towns will grow. Cattle operations. Mines. The men who understand what is coming will own the future.”
“And everybody else?”
“They will work for those men.”
Eli nodded slowly.
“Water.”
Voss’s expression changed for only a fraction of a second.
That was enough.
Eli smiled.
“You do not want my ranch.”
Voss remained silent.
“You want the spring.”
Deputy Kerr looked toward Voss.
That reaction mattered.
Voss lost the last trace of friendliness.
“I cannot imagine who has been telling you stories.”
“You know about the trust.”
Voss stopped smiling entirely.
Behind Eli, the door opened.
Chaska walked onto the porch.
Waya followed.
Then Serina.
Serina carried the silver seal.
Voss stared at it.
For the first time, Eli saw real emotion in the man’s face.
Fear.
Brief.
Controlled.
But unmistakable.
“You,” Voss whispered.
Serina looked directly at him.
“Yes.”
Voss stared at the silver.
“You have no understanding of what you are holding.”
“My mother used to say that men like you often mistake knowing the price of something for understanding its value.”
Eli almost smiled.
Voss did not.
He turned toward the marshal.
“Kerr.”
The deputy swallowed.
“Yes?”
“Execute the order.”
Kerr reached toward the inside of his coat.
Before he could produce the paperwork, Gideon stepped from the house.
Voss froze.
Gideon carried no weapon.
Only papers.
“Hello, Harlan.”
Voss stared.
“Pratt.”
“Been some time.”
“You should have remained outside this matter.”
“I did.”
Gideon looked briefly at Eli.
“Far longer than I should have.”
He handed the documents toward Kerr.
The deputy frowned.
“What are these?”
“The original registration copy of the 1857 valley water trust.”
Voss laughed.
“That agreement was invalidated.”
“Using forged transfers.”
“Prove it.”
Serina stepped forward with her half of the seal.
Eli held the other.
They placed them together.
The pieces fit perfectly.
The hawk became complete.
Three lines representing water flowed beneath its wings.
Kerr stared.
Voss’s jaw tightened.
“A decorative object does not establish anything.”
Gideon nodded.
“That is correct.”
Then Waya whistled.
Hoofbeats answered from the northern ridge.
Voss’s men turned in their saddles.
Riders appeared above the valley.
Dozens of them.
Not soldiers.
Families.
Ranchers.
Apache riders.
Mexican farmers.
Settlers.
Men and women connected to properties Voss had purchased, pressured, surveyed dishonestly, or threatened.
At the front rode Judge Alvarez from Santa Fe.
Voss looked at Gideon.
“You arranged this.”
Gideon shook his head.
“They did.”
Chaska moved forward.
“For five years.”
Eli stared at her.
She met his eyes.
This was another part she had never mentioned.
The search for Eli had never been simply gratitude.
It was about building the alliance before anybody understood how badly they would need it.
Voss laughed again.
This time no confidence accompanied the sound.
“You believe farmers and Indians gathering in a field alters property law?”
Judge Alvarez dismounted.
“No.”
Everyone looked at him.
He held up a leather portfolio.
“But authenticated records of fraud do.”
Voss went still.
The judge continued.
“Your former bookkeeper has spent the last six months providing copies of falsified deeds, fraudulent liens, and payments made to public surveyors.”
Voss’s eyes sharpened.
“My former bookkeeper?”
A voice sounded from behind the group of riders.
“Sorry, Mr. Voss.”
A thin man rode forward.
Geller.
The same enforcer Eli had captured.
His hands were no longer tied.
Eli stared.
Geller appeared vaguely embarrassed.
“Long story.”
Voss’s face twisted.
“You.”
Geller shrugged.
“I told you my father was not present when Samuel Mercer was shot.”
Eli looked at Chaska.
She appeared just as surprised.
Geller continued.
“My father was the man who got Samuel out.”
Silence.
Voss looked murderous.
Geller smiled.
“He worked for your father until he realized Elias intended to control every useful well from here to the northern mesas. Then he changed sides. Spent the rest of his life wishing he had done it sooner.”
Eli stared.
“You knew about my father.”
“Yes.”
“You knew about the letters.”
“Some of them.”
“You allowed us to capture you.”
Geller winced.
“I was hoping your aim might be slightly worse.”
Waya spoke.
“I knew.”
Everyone looked at her.
Chaska frowned.
“You knew what?”
“He surrendered too easily.”
Geller looked offended.
“I was surrounded.”
“You talk excessively when nervous.”
“I was buying time.”
“You still talk excessively.”
Voss suddenly drew his revolver.
Everything moved.
His riders reached for weapons.
Kerr shouted.
Waya raised her bow.
Eli’s hand went toward his holster.
But Chaska stood closest.
She did not draw a weapon.
She stepped between Voss and Eli.
Voss raised the revolver.
Then stopped.
Judge Alvarez had his own gun leveled.
So did Deputy Kerr.
So did half the ranchers behind them.
Voss’s hired riders took one look at the numbers and made what was probably the wisest decision of their lives.
Their weapons lowered.
Harlan Voss stood alone.
His hand shook.
Eli studied him.
“All those years.”
Voss breathed heavily.
“All that property.”
“You do not understand what this valley could become.”
“Maybe not.”
“Rail lines. Industry. Towns.”
“Maybe.”
“You would waste that opportunity on livestock and people who do not even understand the value beneath them?”
Eli looked toward Chaska.
Then toward the gathered families.
Children.
Old men.
Women.
People Voss had reduced to obstacles because obstacles never had to give consent.
Eli turned back.
“I think that is where you and I are different.”
Voss sneered.
“How?”
“You look at land and ask what can be taken from it.”
Eli’s voice was quiet.
“ They taught me to ask who will still need it after I am gone. ”
Voss finally lowered the gun.
Kerr took it from him.
The confrontation ended without another shot.
For several seconds nobody seemed certain what they should do next.
Then Judge Alvarez approached Eli.
“Mr. Mercer.”
“Yes?”
“You and these three women will need to present yourselves in Santa Fe.”
Chaska frowned.
“When?”
“Tomorrow would be inconvenient.”
The judge looked at the crowd.
“I suggest next week.”
Laughter spread through the people gathered around the ranch.
Eli looked toward the porch.
The house.
Calico.
The cottonwoods.
Then Chaska.
She was watching him.
“So,” Eli said, “that was your proposal.”
Chaska shook her head.
“No.”
Eli blinked.
“No?”
“That was the problem.”
“And the proposal?”
Chaska looked at Serina.
Serina smiled.
Waya rolled her eyes.
“Finally.”
Eli looked among them.
“Finally what?”
Chaska came closer.
“The reason we began searching for you before we learned Voss was moving directly against you.”
Eli waited.
Chaska extended her hand.
Not like a lover.
Like someone making an agreement.
“Stand with us as the fourth keeper of the valley trust.”
Eli looked at her outstretched hand.
Then beyond her at the dozens of people who had come.
He thought about nearly twenty years spent convincing himself strength meant needing no one.
He thought about Samuel hiding.
Aiyana living between worlds.
Three frightened women running through a canyon.
And one young cowboy foolish enough to ride toward the screams because riding away felt worse.
He took Chaska’s hand.
“Yes.”
The crowd erupted.
Eli grimaced.
“I preferred it when nobody knew who I was.”
Serina laughed.
“That part of your life is finished.”
Eli believed the story had finally reached its ending.
It had not.
Comments (0)