Chapter 6: THE WELL THAT NEVER CLOSED
Silas Whitlock went to trial four months later.
Horace Bell testified against him.
Taza testified as well.
So did Marshal Mercer.
The forged survey, the payment ledger, testimony concerning the taken children, and multiple accounts of the burning at Caldwell Ranch created a case that even Whitlock’s wealth could not make disappear.
He lost Red Stone Canyon.
He lost the Bar W.
Eventually, he lost his freedom.
The original property lines were restored.
But then Taza’s people made a choice Eli had not expected.
Not everyone returned to Red Stone.
Some did.
Others remained near Caldwell Ranch.
Not as servants.
Not as people dependent on Eli.
As neighbors.
Eli offered them a section of land beside the northern wash as a temporary place to settle.
Temporary lasted for a season.
One season became two.
By the next spring, small homes stood where there had once been empty desert.
Fields had appeared.
A shared corral had been built.
Children ran between the buildings.
And Caldwell Ranch became louder than Eli could ever have imagined.
The twenty-five women who had nearly frightened him senseless that first morning became the center of a story that people in Dry Hollow exaggerated more every time they told it.
In one version, fifty Apache warriors had surrounded Eli’s ranch.
In another, Eli had defeated Silas Whitlock entirely by himself.
According to one especially absurd story told inside the saloon, Naiche had threatened to marry Eli if he refused the women water.
Eli nearly choked when Mercer repeated that version to him.
Naiche found it hilarious.
One evening, nearly a year after the original three women appeared, Eli stood beside his well repairing the same section of fence.
He heard footsteps behind him.
This time, his hand did not move toward his belt.
He already recognized the sound.
Naiche stopped beside him.
“You still bad at fence.”
Eli gave her an offended look.
“Been building fences longer than you’ve been insulting people in English.”
“My English improving.”
“That’s what worries me.”
She smiled.
For months, something quiet had been growing between them.
Neither of them named it.
Taza had certainly noticed.
The twenty-five women had noticed.
Apparently half of Dry Hollow had noticed.
Eli remained stubbornly convinced that nobody had noticed anything.
Then Naiche reached toward him.
She touched the old bracelet.
Eli looked down.
It was still around his wrist.
“You want this back?”
“No.”
Her fingers remained on it.
“You know why I gave?”
“For water.”
She shook her head.
“No.”
Eli waited.
“First day, other two afraid.”
“Of me?”
“Of every man.”
The answer hurt him.
Naiche continued.
“We had been chased from spring. Men said water belonged to them. Said land belonged to them. Everything belonged to them.”
She looked toward Eli’s well.
“When you saw us, you had gun.”
Eli remembered the moment.
“But you put hand away.”
He nodded.
“You gave water.”
“Wasn’t much.”
“To thirsty person, water is much.”
She looked directly into his eyes.
“You did not ask name. Did not ask tribe. Did not ask payment.”
Eli looked away.
“Anybody would’ve done it.”
“No.”
One word.
Absolute certainty.
“No, Eli.”
He knew she was right.
Because once, three years before, someone had refused Sarah.
Naiche stepped closer.
“That bracelet not payment.”
“What was it?”
“A promise.”
Eli frowned.
“What promise?”
“That kindness returns.”
He looked toward the settlement.
Children were chasing one another near the corral.
Taza was arguing with Mercer about a horse.
Two women carried fresh bread toward the communal cooking fire.
Someone had repaired the roof on Eli’s house.
His house.
Not the barn.
Months earlier, Naiche had informed him that continuing to sleep in a barn while a perfectly usable house stood thirty yards away was “stupid.”
So Eli had moved inside.
Another small resurrection.
He surveyed everything around him.
Three years earlier, his land had held cattle, fencing, and silence.
Now it held people.
Arguments.
Meals.
Children.
Work.
Music on certain nights.
Laughter almost every day.
Life.
And all of it had begun because three thirsty strangers had walked toward his well.
“Seems your promise got a little out of hand,” Eli said.
Naiche smiled.
“Yes.”
Eli’s expression grew serious.
“Naiche.”
She waited.
“I loved Sarah.”
“I know.”
“I always will.”
“I know.”
“And Samuel.”
“I know.”
His throat tightened.
“I thought that meant the rest of me belonged back there with them.”
Naiche did not interrupt him.
“But maybe remembering someone isn’t the same as dying with them.”
“No.”
Eli looked at her.
“I don’t know how to do this again.”
“Do what?”
“Care about somebody without spending every minute terrified I’ll lose them.”
Naiche considered his words.
Then she reached out and took his hand.
“You cannot.”
Eli frowned.
“That isn’t especially comforting.”
She smiled.
“To love is to fear loss.”
Her fingers tightened around his.
“But fear is not reason to choose empty life.”
Eli stared down at their joined hands.
Three years building walls.
Three years living inside silence.
Three years convincing himself that emptiness was another word for peace.
It never had been peace.
It had only ever been emptiness.
So Eli squeezed her hand.
And this time, he did not let go.
Comments (0)